16. Season by Season

2005-06
West Yorkshire Association Football League Division One - 3rd/15 (Promoted to NCEFL Division One)
WYAFL League Cup - Semi-Final
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - 1st Round

2006-07
Northern Counties East Football League Division One - 13th/17
FA Vase - 2nd Qualifying Round
NCEFL League Cup - 1st Round
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - 1st Round
Wilkinson Sword Trophy - 1st Round

2007-08
Northern Counties East Football League Division One - 11th/17
FA Cup - Preliminary Replay
FA Vase - 1st Round
NCEFL League Cup - 1st Round
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - Quarter-Final
Wilkinson Sword Trophy - 2nd Round

2008-09
Northern Counties East Football League Division One - 8th/19
FA Cup - Extra Preliminary
FA Vase - 2nd Qualifying Round
NCEFL League Cup - 1st Round
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - 2nd Round
Wilkinson Sword Trophy - 1st Round

2009-10
Northern Counties East Football League Division One - 8th/18
FA Cup - Extra Preliminary
FA Vase - 2nd Qualifying Round
NCEFL League Cup - Quarter-Final
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - Quarter-Final
Wilkinson Sword Trophy - 1st Round
Presidents Cup - 2nd Round

2010-11
Northern Counties East Football League Division One - 8th/20
FA Cup - Preliminary
FA Vase - 2nd Round
NCEFL League Cup - 1st Round
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - 2nd Round
Wilkinson Sword Trophy - 2nd Round
Presidents Cup - 2nd Round

2011-12
Northern Counties East Football League Division One - 10th/20
FA Cup - Extra Preliminary
FA Vase - 1st Round
NCEFL League Cup - 3rd Round
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - 2nd Round
Wilkinson Sword Trophy - 3rd Round
Presidents Cup - 1st Round

2012-13
Northern Counties East Football League Division One - 7th/22
FA Cup - Extra Preliminary
FA Vase - 4th Round
NCEFL League Cup - 1st Round
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - Quarter-Final

2013-14
Northern Counties East Football League Division One - 8th/22
FA Cup - Preliminary
FA Vase - 2nd Round
NCEFL League Cup - 2nd Round
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - 2nd Round

2014-15
Northern Counties East Football League Division One - 5th/22
FA Cup - Preliminary
FA Vase - 1st Round
NCEFL League Cup - 2nd Round
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - 2nd Round

2015-16
Northern Counties East Football League Division One - 4th/21 (Play-Offs)
FA Cup - Preliminary
FA Vase - 2nd Qualifying Round
NCEFL League Cup - 4th Round
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - Quarter-Final

2016-17
Northern Counties East Football League Division One - 3rd/22 (Play-Offs)
FA Cup - Preliminary
FA Vase - 2nd Round
NCEFL League Cup - Semi-Final
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - 1st Round

2017-18
Northern Counties East Football League Division One - 12th/22
FA Cup - Extra Preliminary
FA Vase - 1st Round
NCEFL League Cup - 1st Round
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - Quarter-Final

2018-19
Northern Counties East Football League Division One - 12th/22
FA Cup - N/A
FA Vase - 1st Qualifying Round
NCEFL League Cup - 4th Round
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - 2nd Round

2019-20
North West Counties Football League Division One North- DNF
FA Cup - N/A
FA Vase - 2nd Qualifying Round
NWCFL League Cup - 2nd Round
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - Quarter-Final
NWCFL Division One Cup - Quarter-Final

2020-21
Northern Counties East Football League Division One - 1st/22 (Promoted to NCEFL Premier Division)
FA Cup - N/A
FA Vase - 1st Qualifying Round
NCEFL League Cup - N/A
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - N/A

2021-22
Northern Counties East Football League Premier Division - 9th/20
FA Cup - Preliminary Round
FA Vase - 2nd Round
NCEFL League Cup - 2nd Round
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - Quarter-Final

2022-23
Northern Counties East Football League Premier Division - 3rd/20
FA Cup - Extra Preliminary Round
FA Vase - 2nd Round
NCEFL League Cup - Semi-Final
Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup - Winners